Trivium Pursuit

Something is wrong with this picture


Girl Chopping Onions (1646)
by Gerrit Dou (1613-1675)
Netherlands Baroque painter & draftsman
Student of Rembrandt

Beautiful picture, but something is definitely wrong.

12 Responses to “Something is wrong with this picture”

  1. Carla Says:

    She’s not wearing her onion goggles!

  2. Anna Says:

    What? She’s not crying?

  3. MichelleTordoff (@OurBigHappyFam) Says:

    The little boy looks like he is going to eat an onion?

  4. Kathy Says:

    The chicken doesn’t belong?

  5. Roxanne Stockdale Says:

    the lighting seems off

  6. Audrey Says:

    Seems to me like there ought to be a huge pile of onion skins somewhere if she’s cut up that many onions. Did they have special onion choppers back then?

  7. Nicole Says:

    The girl appears very somber, but I would as well if my task was to chop so many onions. However, it is most queer that the stein or pitcher is overturned in the forefront of the picture.

  8. Gail Says:

    It could be that she is giving “the look” at the painter which translates “Hey, can you put the paintbrush down and help me?”

  9. Sherry Says:

    Well! That was an interesting search & discovery! This is a very innocent looking painting–a slice of life, if you will–but it had strong sexual meaning to the people of the time in which it was painted. As an aside, The green in the painting is supposed to be blue, which I find much more attractive. There are color-corrected photos on the web.

    Other than the fact that the painting appears innocent to modern eyes but isn’t, what I find wrong with the painting is that anyone could stand over that much chopped onion & not be in tears!

  10. KathyW. Says:

    The girl doesn’t look like she is normal kitchen help. She doesn’t have on work clothes, she doesn’t look like she’s in the kitchen.

  11. LaurieBluedorn Says:

    That’s what I was thinking too!

  12. LaurieBluedorn Says:

    Yes, I just found out about the meaning behind the painting. Never knew that before last week.